Almada, Solari and Henry Martín question César Ramos after Pumas and América draw 2-2
Saturday 7 November's derby at the Olímpico Universitario left clashing complaints over the equalising penalty, VAR and a flare-up that brought four bookings. García Orozco backed the penalty but said Huerta should have been sent off.

Pumas and América drew 2-2 on Saturday 7 November at the Estadio Olímpico Universitario in Matchday 16 of the Apertura 2026. Referee César Ramos Palazuelos ended up at the centre of the debate. Guillermo Almada, Esteban Solari and Henry Martín all questioned his decisions, each from a different angle.
What each of them said
Almada argued that the penalty for a hold by Santiago Ramos on Nathan Silva should not have been given. Robert Morales scored it in the 77th minute to make it 2-2. The América coach also criticised VAR for not correcting the call. He said that, with the media narrative that referees favour his club, they end up making unfair decisions. He also mentioned a sending-off that, in his view, was not reflected.
Solari said it is hard to judge without analysing the match calmly. Even so, he felt Pumas were affected by several decisions. He pointed to a clear second-half penalty on Pedro Vite, before América's penalty. Vite was booked. The Argentine insisted Pumas have not been favoured this year, while admitting that his view can change once he sees more footage.
Henry Martín said he told Ramos that a World Cup referee should not miss things like that. He asked what VAR is for and urged officials to use it without fear, for or against any team. The penalty was not reviewed by VAR.
Referee analysis and the flare-up
Roberto García Orozco, Claro Sports' refereeing analyst, backed the penalty, the disallowing of a Morales goal for offside and Vite's yellow card for simulation on the Jugando Claro programme. However, in an analysis published on Monday 9 November he said César Huerta should have been sent off. He called it the most important mistake of the weekend. He also criticised Ramos for physically stepping in to separate players.
The incident came after the 20th minute, with the score at 1-1 following goals by Alejandro Zendejas and Huerta. Huerta and Kevin Álvarez squared up and other players got involved. Huerta made a head movement towards Álvarez. Ramos booked Huerta and Morales for Pumas, and Álvarez and Erick Sánchez for América. Sánchez picked up his fifth yellow card of the tournament.
The draw cost América the overall lead. They are second for now on 30 points and travel to Tigres next. Pumas are 11th on 21 points. They host Monterrey in Matchday 17 and, with a win, would reach 24 and still depend on other results to make the Liguilla.
Sources: Récord · Excélsior (Almada) · Excélsior (Solari) · Sports Illustrated México · Nación Futbol · 88.9 Noticias · TUDN · Claro Sports (García Orozco respalda a Ramos)
Have you seen this round's previews?See previews →More stories
Armando León Shamed on National TV to Clear the Way for Henry Martín: the Controversy That Outraged Mexican FootballAfter being singled out during the Mexico v Jamaica broadcast as a player not good enough for El Tri, fans turned on the Televisa reporter for allegedly sacrificing Armando León's reputation to promote Henry Martín's return.
The Judases of Mexican football: four Expansión clubs exposed for selling their promotion rights for FMF moneyDocuments leaked from the CAS hearing have exposed Piratas de Veracruz, Jaiba Brava, Correcaminos and Alebrijes de Oaxaca, who signed identical letters accepting the closure of Liga MX in exchange for financial support.
Secrecy at CAS and claims of pressure in the Senate: the battle over the return of promotion and relegation in MexicoAfter more than ten hours of confidential hearings at CAS between the FMF and five Liga de Expansión clubs, it emerged on Thursday that the Senate bill remains frozen amid pressure and uncomfortable phone calls.