Previa90Football and NFL analysis and previews
← Stories
StoryBallon d'Or 2026

Did Kane deserve the Ballon d'Or? The World 11 reopens the Mbappé “robbery” debate

Footballers left Harry Kane out of their XI and gave Mbappé the most support among outfield players. A recount of the votes shows how close the Ballon d'Or came to a different winner.

By Monday, November 9, 1:25 PM · 1 min read
Kylian Mbappé in a tuxedo on the left, Harry Kane holding the Ballon d'Or on the right and, in the middle, the World 11 forwards' vote table
Kane finished fifth among the World 11 forwards; Mbappé, first.

Harry Kane won the 2026 Ballon d'Or by 28 points over Mbappé. Two weeks later he finished fifth among the forwards in the FIFPRO World 11 and missed out on the lineup. Kylian Mbappé topped the vote among outfield players with 9,105 of 19,806 footballers backing him, or 46%.

The five most-voted forwards; the top four made the XI.

ForwardWorld 11 support
Kylian Mbappé46.0%
Lamine Yamal37.4%
Lionel Messi29.5%
Erling Haaland28.4%
Harry Kane27.6%

In the Ballon d'Or, 100 journalists voted. Those from Scotland, Greece and Ukraine left Mbappé out of their top ten and gave Kane 21 points between them. Remove those ballots from the count and the Englishman would still have won by seven points.

The Scottish ballot put Kane first. Had the 15 points for that first place gone from the Englishman to Mbappé, the Frenchman would have won 1,042 to 1,040. In the actual count, Kane collected 40 first-place votes to Mbappé's 23.

2026 Ballon d'Or points in each scenario.

ScenarioKaneMbappé
Actual result1,0551,027
Without the Scotland, Greece and Ukraine ballots1,0341,027
If Scotland's first place had gone to Mbappé1,0401,042

Both votes assessed almost the same season, World Cup included. Messi went from fifth overall in the Ballon d'Or to third among the World 11 forwards, with 29.5% support.

Does voting from the pitch make the result more objective?

The World 11 draws on the experience of thousands of professionals, but the choice is still a personal one. Each footballer picked three names per position and could vote for both Kane and Mbappé on the same ballot. In the Ballon d'Or, each journalist ranked ten candidates and gave the most points to the first.

The World 11 weakens the idea that the Ballon d'Or represents a consensus across all of football. The award's credibility also depends on how it explains its most disputed ballots.

Sources: FIFPRO: Who received the most votes and who narrowly missed out · FIFPRO: The 2026 FIFPRO World 11 in numbers

Have you seen this round's previews?See previews →

More stories